What happens if export pallets fail an ISPM 15 inspection? An export shipment with noncompliant ISPM 15 wood packaging can be held or refused entry, while authorities may require the wood packaging or shipment to be treated, re-exported, destroyed or otherwise safeguarded. The exact response depends on the destination country and violation. Delays, additional handling and transportation costs, and in some circumstances financial penalties can follow.
The product is fine, the paperwork is in order and the shipment has travelled thousands of miles. Then an inspector at the destination spots a problem with the wood packaging underneath it.
Perhaps an IPPC mark is missing or illegible. Maybe the pallet shows evidence of improper repair, untreated wood or live pests. Suddenly, a relatively inexpensive pallet or wooden dunnage component has become a problem for the entire shipment.
For a shipper, that is why ISPM 15 is much more than a pallet-purchasing issue.
What are inspectors looking for?
Countries that have adopted ISPM 15 use the standard to reduce the movement of wood-boring pests through international trade. Solid wood pallets and other regulated wood packaging generally must be treated according to an approved method and carry the prescribed IPPC mark.
Problems can include missing or illegible marks, incorrectly formatted marks, signs of noncompliant repairs, bark beyond permitted tolerances or evidence of pests. If a mark has faded or become difficult to read, see What If the IPPC/ISPM 15 Stamp on a Pallet Is Unreadable?
Repairs can create a different compliance problem. Simply replacing a broken board with heat-treated lumber does not necessarily preserve the pallet’s certification. Our guide, Does a Repaired ISPM 15 Pallet Need to Be Heat Treated Again?, looks more closely at the repair requirements.
For shipments entering the United States, USDA APHIS says regulated wood packaging must be pest-free, debarked, appropriately treated or fumigated and marked with the ISPM 15 logo. APHIS is equally direct about the consequence: shipments containing noncompliant wood packaging will not be allowed to enter the country. USDA APHIS provides current wood packaging material import guidance.
That doesn’t necessarily mean every violation produces exactly the same outcome. What happens next depends on the circumstances and the instructions issued by the authorities.
A pallet problem can become a shipment problem
This is the part that can catch exporters by surprise. The value of the pallet may be insignificant compared with the cargo sitting on it, but inspectors aren’t evaluating the pallet’s purchase price. They are enforcing a phytosanitary import requirement.
CFIA warns Canadian exporters that noncompliant wood packaging can result in the shipment being refused at the destination, returned to Canada or destroyed at the discretion of the receiving country. CFIA also identifies potential financial penalties at destination and, where Canadian requirements have been violated, possible administrative monetary penalties or prosecution in Canada. CFIA provides guidance for Canadian exporters using wood packaging material.
The indirect costs can be just as painful: port or terminal charges, delays, additional transportation, product disruption and the time required to resolve the problem with customers, brokers and authorities.
What should you do if a shipment is held?
Start with the official notice or instructions from the inspecting authority rather than attempting to solve the problem independently.
For U.S. imports, APHIS and U.S. Customs and Border Protection use an Emergency Action Notification process for certain noncompliance situations, and APHIS provides resources for importers dealing with an EAN arising from ISPM 15 noncompliance.
The importer, customs broker, exporter and freight provider may all need to be involved depending on where the shipment is located and what action authorities require.
Once the immediate shipment is addressed, trace the pallet or wood packaging back through the supply chain. Identify the supplier, preserve photographs and documentation, and determine whether the problem is isolated or could affect other shipments using packaging from the same source.
If other loads are still sitting in your warehouse on questionable pallets, that’s the inexpensive place to catch them.
Prevention is cheaper at the shipping dock
For companies exporting regularly, ISPM 15 compliance should be built into pallet procurement and shipping procedures rather than treated as something the pallet supplier handles in the background.
Buy regulated export pallets from properly authorized sources. Train shipping personnel to recognize the basic IPPC mark. Watch for illegible stamps, questionable repairs, soil, pest evidence and pallets that have slipped into the export inventory from an unknown source. Companies considering secondary-market export pallets should also see Should I Buy Used Heat-Treated Pallets for International Shipping?
Physical condition matters too. ISPM 15 compliance doesn’t make a damaged pallet safe for another load. Broken boards, damaged stringers or blocks, exposed fasteners and other structural problems may be reasons to remove a pallet from service regardless of its certification status. See When Should a Wood Pallet Be Taken Out of Service?
And don’t assume that because a pallet made one international trip successfully it will automatically pass the next inspection. Heat treatment itself doesn’t expire, but repairs, damage, deteriorating marks, contamination or pest exposure can change the picture.
A compliant pallet is a relatively small part of the cost of an international shipment. Finding the wrong pallet before loading is inconvenient. Finding it at the port of entry can be considerably more expensive.
Find answers to more questions about ISPM 15, export pallets, pallet repair and international shipping at our Pallet Problems hub.
Have a pallet problem we haven’t covered? Send us your question. We may answer it directly or use it as the basis for a future Pallet Problems article.
Rick LeBlanc, EMBA, is the founder and editor of Reusable Packaging News (subscribe to the free newsletter) and editor of Western Pallet Magazine. A supply chain journalist with more than 30 years of experience, he specializes in pallets, reusable packaging, material handling and related operations. Rick is co-author of Pallets: A North American Perspective and Pallets & Progress: A Collected History of Pallets and Palletized Handling 1922–1945. He is also an advisory board member of the Virginia Tech Center for Packaging and Unit Load Design. Read Rick’s full bio.


