For years, extended producer responsibility for packaging was something that happened in Europe and Canada. Not anymore. Seven states have enacted packaging EPR laws: California, Colorado, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Oregon and Washington. Oregon and Colorado are already invoicing producers. If you make, buy or ship transport packaging, the cost of single-use material is about to show up on paper in a way it never has before.

California is the state to watch. The SB 54 regulations took effect May 1, and unlike Oregon and Colorado, California gives business-to-business packaging no pass. Stretch film, strapping, corner boards and one-way shippers are all in scope. The law calls for 25% less plastic packaging by 2032, with a 10% cut due in 2027, part of it through reuse and refill. It also requires producers to pay $500 million a year for ten years into a mitigation fund, much of it directed to low-income and fenceline communities that live beside the plants, ports and landfills.
Then the lawyers arrived. Environmental groups sued in June, arguing the final rules are full of loopholes. Weeks later, 17 states and the National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors filed a federal suit calling the law unconstitutional. They have asked the court to halt the entire program; that hearing is set for January 15, 2027. Meanwhile, a federal judge upheld Oregon’s law on August 27, and that ruling is now on appeal.
So one California lawsuit could loosen the rules and the other could tighten them. Neither has stopped anything. Anyone planning around SB 54 going away is placing a bet, not making a plan.
The program has its own troubles. According to multiple attorneys advising producers, only about half of the companies obligated in California have registered. That matters to everyone who did sign up, because the same costs spread across fewer payers means bigger invoices. Many companies are also struggling to produce credible short-term plans for cutting plastic by the statutory deadlines. Even Circular Action Alliance (CAA), the producer group running the program, has said in its draft program plan that it may seek a three-year exemption from the 10% source reduction target.
Here is where our industry comes in. The old take-make-waste model worked financially because someone else paid for the waste. EPR ends that arrangement. Every pound of single-use packaging shipped into California becomes a reported number with a fee attached, year after year.
Reusable transport packaging changes the math. Packaging that meets California’s definition of reusable, which includes being designed for multiple trips and supported by a system that actually gets it back, is not treated as single-use and is not assessed fees. Replacing single-use plastic with it can also count toward the source reduction targets companies are having so much trouble meeting. And this is not a plastics story or a wood story. A pooled wood pallet, a plastic tote, a steel rack and a reusable pallet wrap all earn their keep the same way: by making trip after trip instead of one.
The patchwork is also changing the national conversation. Seven sets of definitions, deadlines and fee schedules are hard on any company shipping across state lines, and frustrated producers are increasingly asking whether one federal framework would be simpler. No such bill is before Congress, and analysts doubt one is coming soon. Still, industry itself is now raising the question.
One more thing to watch: CAA is growing quickly, and its careers page says as much. It is also building outside partnerships. On September 30, CAA announced it is investing in Closed Loop Partners’ Reuse Cities Initiative to help scale reuse systems in California. That effort is aimed at consumer packaging, not pallets and totes, but it shows where the money and attention are heading. Reusable transport packaging suppliers and users should be introducing themselves now, while the rules are still being written.
The courts will take years to sort this out. The economics will not wait that long.
The author is Patrick Owens, Chief Principal Consultant, Sustainable Supply Chain Transformation, Recirculated.
Expert guest authors are encouraged to share their perspectives at PackagingRevolution.net. Reach out to rick@packagingrevolution.net to find out more. (subscribe to the free newsletter).


